FREMONT, Ohio — Sandusky County voters have elected Republican Party Chairman Justin Smith to help manage a county facing a projected $4.3 million budget shortfall, despite a previous government employment record that includes a forced resignation, repeated court errors and political activity during work hours. One of those errors left a protection order active for more than two months and was followed by a woman’s arrest for allegedly violating an order that should have been dismissed.
Smith, whose own Republican Central Committee appointed him county commissioner in April, defeated Democrat Jill Simpson, a former United Way and Chamber of Commerce executive with decades of management experience. He received 12,477 votes, or 56.15%, to Simpson’s 9,745 votes, or 43.85%, according to unofficial election results from the Sandusky County Board of Elections.
Republican Richard J. Farmer II also defeated Democrat Kurtis A. Kuhl, 13,017 votes to 9,146, or 58.73% to 41.27%. Farmer will replace retiring Commissioner Russ Zimmerman in January, leaving Republicans in control of all three commission seats alongside Smith and Commissioner Scott Miller.
The victories come as Sandusky County confronts one of its most serious financial challenges in recent years. Commissioners have frozen nonessential spending and hiring, county records show substantial spending beyond budgeted amounts in at least one department, and the county auditor has warned that sheriff’s deputies and jail employees could face missed paychecks unless officials resolve a funding shortfall.
Smith has served on the commission since April 20, when his party organization selected him to replace departing Commissioner Charlie Schwochow. He was not a member of the board when the original 2026 budget was adopted, but he has participated in the county’s response to the financial emergency since it became public in September.
County’s budget crisis threatens sheriff’s payroll
Sandusky County officials identified a projected $4.3 million shortfall over the summer and imposed a spending and hiring freeze effective Sept. 1. The situation became more urgent in October when Auditor Jerri Miller warned that the sheriff’s office could run out of appropriated funding to pay its employees.
In an Oct. 19 letter to Sheriff Christopher Hilton, Miller estimated that the department may already have exceeded its 2026 budget by $200,000 to $300,000, according to the Fremont News-Messenger. She warned that without a solution, the county could be unable to issue paychecks for the period covering Nov. 22 through Dec. 5 and subsequent payroll periods.
“If a solution cannot be found, the warrants for Payroll 24 will be the last ones issued for the impacted sheriff’s employees,” Miller wrote, according to the News-Messenger’s reporting.
The sheriff’s office employs approximately 80 people, although some positions are funded through grants or other agencies. A typical payroll period costs approximately $230,000. The department operates the county jail and provides law enforcement services, making its financial problems particularly consequential for county employees and residents.
Hilton told commissioners during an Oct. 29 meeting that he was examining spending reductions, including changes to overtime, training and equipment purchases. The sheriff also identified rising costs for medical care provided to inmates, an expense the county cannot simply eliminate.
Commissioner Scott Miller said Nov. 1 that the county could meet its remaining 2026 obligations by reducing expenses and redirecting money from future projects, according to reporting on the financial crisis. The auditor’s earlier warning identified a specific payroll funding problem that requires adjustments to the sheriff’s appropriations. A subsequent resolution of that issue has not been independently established in the available reporting.
The problems extend beyond the sheriff’s office. As TiffinOhio.net reported in September, county records showed that General Fund payments to the Department of Job and Family Services totaled $1,304,132.36 by Aug. 27, exceeding the $900,000 budgeted amount by $404,132.36 with four months remaining in the year. The records did not establish how much that overage contributed to the countywide shortfall.
Smith joined Miller and Zimmerman in signing a Sept. 4 public statement describing the spending freeze as a “pause on various areas of spending” while officials reviewed county finances. The statement did not disclose the projected $4.3 million shortfall or tell residents that hiring had been frozen.
At a Sept. 29 candidate forum hosted by the Fremont NAACP, Smith defended his involvement in the county’s financial response.
“I did not cause the problem, but I am working to fix the problem,” Smith said. He told attendees that commissioners had resumed budget hearings after years without them and were meeting with departments to examine their spending.
Smith’s campaign also made fiscal management a selling point. His campaign website credited him with “protecting taxpayer dollars through responsible budgeting” and promised “balanced budgets, responsible spending, and efficient government that delivers results.”
Personnel records reveal serious errors in Smith’s previous county job
Before voters elected Smith to oversee county finances, his record in another Sandusky County government position had already drawn scrutiny.
Personnel records obtained by TiffinOhio.net documented repeated problems during Smith’s employment as a deputy clerk at Sandusky County Court District No. 1 in Clyde. Smith resigned in March 2019 after being reprimanded over his work performance and allegations that he conducted political business during county work hours.
Among the most consequential errors was Smith’s failure to enter the dismissal of a temporary protection order in February 2018. The order should have been dismissed Feb. 27 but remained active in court records until May 10. A woman was arrested in Ottawa County on May 9 for allegedly violating the order, one day before Smith finally entered the dismissal. The charges against her were subsequently dropped.
The personnel file documented another incident in September 2018 in which Smith and another clerk restored driving privileges to a defendant without authorization from the judge. The clerk’s office later had to send corrective communications to the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles.
An Aug. 31, 2018, reprimand identified Smith’s repeated failure to properly serve eviction paperwork and problems with court records, including illegible handwriting and cases left open. In a November memorandum, then-Clerk of Courts Tracy Overmyer criticized Smith’s knowledge of his duties and the accuracy of his work.
Overmyer also examined two months of Smith’s outgoing telephone calls and concluded that he had repeatedly contacted the Board of Elections during work hours while conducting business associated with his political role. One documented call occurred at 4:25 p.m. on Feb. 6, 2019, the filing deadline for the May primary, when Smith checked which candidates had submitted petitions.
Smith acknowledged making that call but denied making other political calls during work hours.
After leaving the court, Smith told the Fremont News-Messenger that he had been forced to resign. “I have done nothing wrong,” he said, describing the court as a negative work environment. An earlier performance evaluation had commended his work ethic while also identifying concerns with his attention to detail and handwriting.
Smith’s court employment history became public again when the Republican Central Committee selected him for the commissioner vacancy in April. His subsequent election gives him responsibility for decisions involving a substantially larger government operation, including the county budget and the funding of departments facing financial pressure.
His own party committee put him in office
Smith’s path to the commission began with an appointment by the political organization he has chaired since 2008.
After Commissioner Charlie Schwochow resigned effective March 31, the Sandusky County Republican Central Committee convened April 18 to fill the vacancy. Smith was among nine applicants seeking the position. Because he was a candidate, Vice Chairman Ben Decker presided over the meeting.
Thirty-two of the committee’s 41 voting members attended. After three rounds of voting, the committee selected Smith over the other finalists, Sandusky Township Trustee Paul Lotycz and retired accountant Barbara Bristley. Smith was sworn in two days later.
The committee also selected Smith as the Republican candidate for the November election, placing its longtime chairman on the ballot to serve the remainder of Schwochow’s term through Jan. 2, 2029.
Smith had previously represented Fremont’s First Ward on City Council and served on the Sandusky County Board of Elections. His political career gave him extensive experience in elections and party leadership, while his earlier employment in the court system left a documented record of mistakes and reprimands.
Simpson offered voters a substantially different professional background. She had served as president and chief executive of United Way of Sandusky County since 2022 and previously led the Chamber of Commerce of Sandusky County. Her career also included management and workforce development positions with state and county organizations. Her campaign said she earned a master’s degree in business administration from Tiffin University.
At the September NAACP forum, Simpson identified stabilizing county finances as her first priority. She advocated improved budget forecasting and closer examination of departmental spending, including whether staffing changes could reduce overtime costs.
Voters chose Smith by a margin of 2,732 votes, retaining the commissioner who had already been serving during the county’s response to its budget crisis.
In the second commission contest, Farmer campaigned on his own criticism of county budgeting. He told the September forum that he had examined several years of financial records and warned commissioners in February that their spending plan was unsustainable. Farmer will join the commission Jan. 1, replacing Zimmerman, who was serving when the 2026 budget was adopted.
Kuhl, Farmer’s Democratic opponent, called for making county financial information easier for residents to examine without having to file public-records requests. The two Republican victories preserve unified party control of the commission as it prepares its 2027 budget.
Fremont mayor defended Smith five days before election
Smith also received a public defense from Fremont Mayor Danny Sanchez during the final days of the campaign, despite the mayor’s stated intention to remain outside the commissioner race.
In an Oct. 29 Facebook post, Sanchez criticized comments questioning Smith’s qualifications because he reportedly did not own a home or other property in Sandusky County. The mayor reproduced the criticism in a screenshot, published a photograph of himself standing alongside Smith and wrote a lengthy statement praising his longtime friend.
“I had every intention of staying out of this County Commissioner race,” Sanchez began. He said Smith had been a longtime friend who had served the community with dedication, adding that he respected both candidates.
“Since when did owning a home become a qualification for public service?” Sanchez asked.
Sanchez argued that questioning someone’s ability to manage public finances based on homeownership was disrespectful to residents who rent. He said community service and character should carry more weight than property ownership.
The original social media criticism addressed Smith’s reported lack of property ownership, which is not a qualification for serving as county commissioner. Sanchez’s objection to that argument did not require him to assess the former court employee’s job performance or his role in county finances.
But the mayor went considerably further than challenging the homeownership argument. He praised Smith’s years in public service, described their personal relationship and publicly defended him just five days before voters decided whether to keep him in office.
“I am proud of my friendship with Justin Smith, and I respect the years he has devoted to serving this community,” Sanchez wrote.
Sanchez also said he respected Simpson and her willingness to serve. His post devoted substantially more attention to defending Smith, while offering no discussion of the personnel records documenting Smith’s court errors or the financial problems facing the commission on which he was serving.
The mayor characterized his intervention as an appeal for respect and fairness. By publicly championing his longtime friend during the final days of the election, Sanchez added his own standing as Fremont’s mayor to a defense of Smith’s candidacy, whether or not he intended the statement as a formal endorsement.
A Republican commission now owns the financial decisions
Smith and Farmer’s victories preserve Republican control of Sandusky County government at a time when commissioners face difficult spending decisions that will affect county employees and the services residents depend upon.
Smith’s forced resignation from the court system was documented years before his appointment and election. His personnel records describe errors with tangible consequences, including a protection order that remained active until after the woman subject to it had been arrested. Those records were available to voters before they elected him to the commission.
The county’s financial problems were also public before Election Day. Smith campaigned on responsible budgeting while serving on a board that had frozen spending and hiring. Farmer told voters he had warned about unsustainable spending months earlier. Both now have responsibility for the county’s financial course, although Farmer will not take office until January.
The next immediate test rests with Smith and the current commission. Auditor Jerri Miller’s October warning identified the Nov. 22-Dec. 5 payroll period as a potential breaking point for sheriff’s employees if funding adjustments were not made. The county must also reconcile its projected shortfall before the end of the year, as officials prepare a new spending plan for 2027.
County employees waiting for their next paychecks, and residents relying on the sheriff’s office and other public services, have a direct stake in how commissioners handle those decisions.