Conservative activists are threatening primary challenges against Republican lawmakers who vote to retain Ohio House Speaker Matt Huffman, as the party’s internal fighting intensifies following its November 3 election losses.
The confrontation erupted into a public feud Monday, with state Rep. Gary Click, R-Vickery, defending Huffman against conservative critics who blame the speaker for Republicans losing their veto-proof House majority. The dispute now pits organizations that ordinarily support the same conservative causes against one another ahead of Tuesday’s Republican leadership vote.
Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom, an anti-vax extremist group led by Stephanie Stock, has launched an “Anyone But Huffman” campaign encouraging supporters to contact Republican lawmakers. Its website provides a prewritten email threatening to work against any legislator who votes to keep Huffman.
“I will be watching for your vote and will be working to primary you in the next election if you vote to re-elect Huffman as Speaker,” the message states.
The organization accuses Huffman of obstructing legislation concerning vaccine mandates and medical freedom. On Monday, it also accused him of blocking a 2025 proposal to restrict state Medicaid funding for abortions and challenged conservative organizations endorsing his leadership.
Conservatives clash over Huffman’s future
The immediate dispute followed a November 16 appeal from John Stover, president of Ohio Value Voters, urging supporters to contact Republican House members and demand they retain Huffman as speaker.
In an accompanying message to lawmakers, Stover praised the House majority leadership for advancing parental rights and traditional family values. He encouraged supporters to call their representatives by Tuesday, November 17, the date of the Republican leadership vote.
Marcell Strbich, who unsuccessfully sought the Republican nomination for Ohio secretary of state earlier this year, attacked the endorsement Monday, accusing Huffman’s supporters of attempting to preserve failed leadership through political patronage.
He called it “last minute-desperation to cling to FAILED STATUS QUO leadership” and directed followers to FireMattHuffman.com, a website organizing opposition to Huffman before the caucus vote.
The website attacks Huffman’s handling of the $600 million Cleveland Browns stadium subsidy, his caucus’s spending against Republican incumbents during the May primary and legislation that never reached a House floor vote. It provides lawmakers’ contact information and prewritten opposition messages.
The site’s legal disclosures identify its operator as “Ohio Forward Fund,” but provide no officers or organizational address. Stock’s Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom operates its own separately branded anti-Huffman campaign with similar organizing tools.
Gary Click defends Huffman and fires back at Strbich
Click, who represents Seneca and Sandusky counties, responded directly to Strbich, defending Ohio Value Voters and arguing that blaming individual Republican leaders for the election results ignored broader national political trends.
Click accused Huffman’s critics of participating in a “circular firing squad” and claimed Republicans might have lost their House majority entirely without the speaker’s leadership.
“No one is better equipped than the guy doing it now,” Click wrote, warning that replacing Huffman could lead to additional Republican defeats in 2028.
Click also took a swipe at Strbich’s political ambitions, suggesting he look to U.S. Rep. Jim Jordan as an example of someone who understands the political moment.
Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom subsequently challenged Click directly, asking, “Gary, please explain how you can support Huffman after this?”
In another Monday post, Click warned Republicans that their political opponents were watching the infighting with “popcorn in hand” and urged conservatives to stop attacking their own party.
Election losses fuel the leadership fight
The feud follows an election in which Democrats won the governor’s office and flipped at least eight Republican-held Ohio House seats. Four additional House races remained uncalled as of Monday morning, according to unofficial results. Republicans will retain control of the chamber but no longer have the 60 votes needed to override a governor’s veto without Democratic support.
The political fallout has also reached activists who backed Vivek Ramaswamy’s unsuccessful campaign for governor. Stock’s organization awarded Ramaswamy an A in its 2026 voter guide, while Strbich publicly endorsed him shortly before the election. Ramaswamy lost to Democrat Amy Acton, 52.3% to 44.4%, according to unofficial returns.
TiffinOhio.net previously examined how conservative activists rallied behind Ramaswamy despite their longstanding opposition to establishment Republican leadership. They are now demanding accountability from the House speaker following the party’s losses.
Huffman, however, has publicly expressed confidence that he will remain speaker. Speaking to reporters November 10, he said he had personally contacted approximately 80% of Republican caucus members and received assurances of their support. He acknowledged that roughly 10 to 12 members wanted further discussions but predicted only a handful would oppose him.
“I don’t think it’s close,” Huffman told the Statehouse News Bureau.
Former Speaker Jason Stephens has been mentioned as a possible challenger. Stephens previously won the speakership in 2023 with Democratic support, defeating the candidate favored by most House Republicans.
Republicans are scheduled to choose their leadership Tuesday, November 17, ahead of the formal speaker election when the new General Assembly convenes in January. The caucus vote will also identify which lawmakers backed Huffman, giving activists who have threatened future primary challenges a record of where each member stands.